آفاق وحدود الرقابة الدستورية على الإغفال التشريعي

I. Primary References

1. Abu Mattar, M. A. (2018). Al-Waseet fi al-qada' al-dostouri, al-qada' al-dostouri fi Filastin wa Misr, dirasah tahliliyah muqaranah [The intermediary in constitutional judiciary, constitutional judiciary in Palestine and Egypt, a comparative analytical study]. Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya & Dar Al-Nahda Al-Ilmiya.

2. Abu Mattar, M. A. (2023). Nitaq al-tashri'at al-khadi'ah li-raqabat al-dostouriyah wafqan lil-qanoun wa ijtihadat al-qada' al-dostouri fi Filastin, dirasah tahliliyah [The scope of legislation subject to constitutional review according to law and jurisprudence of constitutional judiciary in Palestine, an analytical study]. Journal of Law - Kuwait University, 47(1).

3. Abu Mattar, M. A. (2019). Ikhtisas al-Mahkamah al-Dostouriyah al-Ulya bil-tafsir wafqan lil-tashri' al-Filastini wa al-Misri, dirasah muqaranah fi daw' ijtihadat al-qada' al-dostouri [The jurisdiction of the Supreme Constitutional Court in interpretation according to Palestinian and Egyptian legislation, a comparative study in light of constitutional jurisprudence]. Al-Azhar University Journal, Humanities Series, 21(2).

4. Abu Younis, M. W. (n.d.). Hudoud al-raqabah al-dostouriyah ala al-ighfal al-tashri'i fi qada' al-Mahkamah al-Dostouriyah al-Ulya [Limits of constitutional review on legislative omission in the jurisprudence of the Supreme Constitutional Court].

5. Al-Bahri, H. M. (2021). Al-qada' al-dostouri, dirasah muqaranah [Constitutional judiciary, a comparative study] (2nd ed.). Faculty of Law, Damascus University.

6. Al-Wahidi, F. (2004). Al-qada' al-dostouri fi Filastin, wafqan li-ahkam al-qanoun al-asasi al-mu'addal wa mashrou' qanoun al-Mahkamah al-Dostouriyah al-Ulya, dirasah muqaranah [Constitutional judiciary in Palestine, according to the provisions of the amended basic law and the draft law of the Supreme Constitutional Court, a comparative study]. Al-Miqdad Press.

7. Bahloul, A. S. (n.d.). Dawabit al-raqabah al-dostouriyah ala al-lawa'ih, dirasah tahliliyah li-ahkam al-qada' al-dostouri al-Misri [Controls of constitutional review on regulations, an analytical study of the rulings of the Egyptian constitutional judiciary]. The Legal Journal - Faculty of Law, Zagazig University.

8. Hussein, A. S. M. (2025). Nazariyat al-dostouriyah al-raqmiyah wa himayat al-qiyam wa al-huqouq al-dostouriyah fi al-alam al-raqmi [The theory of digital constitutionalism and the protection of constitutional values and rights in the digital world]. Journal of Legal and Economic Sciences, 67(2).

9. Hussein, A. S. M. (2025). Nazariyat al-dostouriyah al-alamiyah wa athar al-ma'ayir al-dawliyah ala al-dasatir al-wataniyah [The theory of global constitutionalism and the impact of international standards on national constitutions]. Journal of Legal and Economic Sciences, 67(1).

10. Hussein, M. M. (n.d.). Dawr al-qada' al-dostouri fi al-raqabah ala al-ta'dilat al-dostouriyah [The role of the constitutional judiciary in reviewing constitutional amendments]. Journal of Law - Imam Al-Kadhum College.

11. Dalalshah, I. E. (2022). Al-ighfal al-tashri'i wa sultat al-qadi al-dostouri fi al-raqabah alayh, dirasah muqaranah [Legislative omission and the authority of the constitutional judge in its review, a comparative study] (Master's thesis). Al-Quds University, Palestine.

12. Siddiq, S. (2014). Al-ighfal al-tashri'i wa subul mu'alajatih [Legislative omission and means of addressing it]. Journal of International Law and Business.

13. Taleb, A. (2025). Dawr al-qanoun al-dostouri fi muwajahat tahaddiyat al-mujtama' al-tiknolouji [The role of constitutional law in facing the challenges of technological society]. Journal of Law and Political Sciences - Abbas Laghrour University, 12(2), 55-77.

14. Ali, Al-Hussein A. S. (2022). Raqabat al-ighfal wa wasa'il mu'alajatiha fi al-qada' al-dostouri wa atharuha ala al-islah al-tashri'i [Omission review and means of addressing it in constitutional judiciary and its impact on legislative reform]. Journal of Legal and Economic Research, (79).

15. Farraj, I., & Al-Rimawi, A. M. (2025). Tahaddiyat al-qada' al-dostouri fi mu'alajat al-faragh al-tashri'i [Challenges of constitutional judiciary in addressing the legislative vacuum]. The Arab Journal for Arts and Human Studies, Arab Foundation for Education, Science and Arts.

II. Secondary References

1. Abu Al-Enein, M. M. (2013). Al-inhiraf al-tashri'i wa al-raqabah ala dostouriyatih, dirasah tatbiqiyah: Al-kitab al-thani [Legislative deviation and the review of its constitutionality, an applied study: The second book]. National Center for Legal Publications.

2. Al-Jamal, Y. (2006). Al-qada' al-dostouri fi Misr [Constitutional judiciary in Egypt]. Dar Al-Nahda.

3. Al-Saadi, M. S. (1979). Tafsir al-nusus fi al-qanoun wa al-shari'ah [Interpretation of texts in law and Sharia] (1st ed.). Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

4. Al-Sanhuri, A. R. (1952). Mukhalafat al-tashri' lil-dostour wa al-inhiraf fi isti'mal al-sultah al-tashri'iyah [Violation of the constitution by legislation and deviation in the use of legislative power]. Journal of the State Council, 2.

5. Al-Ghafloul, E. A. (2003). Fikrat adam al-ikhtisas al-salbi lil-musharri': Dirasah muqaranah [The concept of negative non-competence of the legislator: A comparative study] (2nd ed.). Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

6. Al-Madhoun, D. S. (2014). Al-raqabah al-qada'iyah ala dostouriyat al-qawanin, dirasah muqaranah bayna Amrika wa Misr wa Filastin [Judicial review of the constitutionality of laws, a comparative study between America, Egypt, and Palestine] (Master's thesis). Academy of Administration and Politics for Postgraduate Studies, Gaza, Palestine.

7. Al-Murr, A. (2003). Al-raqabah ala dostouriyat al-qawanin fi mlamhiha al-asasiyah [Review of the constitutionality of laws in its basic features]. René-Jean Dupuy Center for Law and Development.

8. Baljilali, K. (2017). Al-ikhtisas al-salbi lil-musharri' wa al-raqabah al-dostouriyah alayh: Dirasah muqaranah [The negative competence of the legislator and constitutional review over it: A comparative study]. Al-Oustadh Al-Bahith Journal for Legal and Political Studies, (6).

9. Jafar, M. A. Q. (1999). Al-raqabah ala dostouriyat al-qawanin, dirasah muqaranah tatbiqiyah [Review of the constitutionality of laws, an applied comparative study] (2nd ed.). Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

10. Hussein, A. H. S. (2009). Dawr al-qadi al-dostouri fi al-raqabah ala al-sultah al-taqdiriyah lil-musharri' [The role of the constitutional judge in reviewing the discretionary power of the legislator]. Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

11. Haidar, M. (2010). Mu'alajat imtina' al-barlaman an mumarasat ikhtisasihi al-tashri'i [Addressing the parliament's abstention from exercising its legislative competence]. Al-Muhaqqiq Al-Hilli Journal for Legal and Political Sciences, 7(4).

12. Dallah, S. (n.d.). Al-qanoun al-dostouri wa al-nuzum al-siyasiyah [Constitutional law and political systems].

13. Lashhab, H. (n.d.). Al-raqabah al-siyasiyah ala dostouriyat al-qawanin [Political review of the constitutionality of laws]. Journal of Judicial Jurisprudence, (4), Mohamed Khider University of Biskra. Chitor, J. (n.d.). Al-raqabah al-qada'iyah ala dostouriyat al-qawanin [Judicial review of the constitutionality of laws]. Journal of Judicial Jurisprudence, (4), Mohamed Khider University of Biskra.

14. Salman, A. M. (n.d.). Raqabat al-ighfal al-tashri'i [Review of legislative omission]. Al-Dostouriyah Journal, (15).

15. Salman, A. M. (2019). Al-raqabah al-qada'iyah ala qusour al-tanzim al-tashri'i [Judicial review of the deficiency of legislative organization]. Al-Dostouriyah Journal (Golden Jubilee Issue of the Supreme Constitutional Court).

16. Salman, A. M. (1995). Raqabat dostouriyat al-qawanin [Review of the constitutionality of laws] (1st ed.). Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi.

17. Sayed, R. E. (2009). Al-wajeez fi al-da'wa al-dostouriyah ma'a muqaddimah lil-qada' al-dostouri fi kull min Faransa wa al-Wilayat al-Muttahidah al-Amrikiyah [The concise guide to constitutional lawsuits with an introduction to constitutional judiciary in France and the USA] (Revised ed.). Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

18. Abdel Salam, A. (n.d.). Al-raqabah ala dostouriyat al-qawanin [Review of the constitutionality of laws]. Hamada Press. 20. Azzaoui, A. (2010).

19. Al-raqabah ala al-soulouk al-salbi lil-musharri', al-ighfal al-tashri'i namoudhajan [Review of the negative behavior of the legislator, legislative omission as a model]. Journal of Legal, Administrative and Political Sciences - Abou Bekr Belkaid University, (10).

20. Othamnia, L. (2005). Al-tafsir fi al-maddah al-jaza'iyah wa atharuhu ala harakat al-tashri' [Interpretation in criminal matters and its impact on the legislative movement]. Journal of Human Sciences - Mohamed Khider University of Biskra, 7(2).

21. Azzaoui, A. (2009). Dawapit tawzi' al-ikhtisas bayna al-sultatayn al-tashri'iyah wa al-tanfidhiyah, dirasah muqaranah: Vol. 1 [Controls of the distribution of jurisdiction between the legislative and executive authorities, a comparative study: Vol. 1]. Dar El Gharb for Publishing and Distribution.

22. Farraj, Z. (1999). Al-nuzum al-siyasiyah wa mabadi' al-qanoun al-dostouri [Political systems and principles of constitutional law]. Al-Jalaa Library.

23. Kilali, Z. (2013). Al-ighfal al-tashri'i wa al-raqabah al-dostouriyah alayh [Legislative omission and constitutional review over it] (Master's thesis). Abou Bekr Belkaid University, Tlemcen, Algeria.

24. Nawayji, M. (2008). Al-tafsir al-mounshi' lil-qadi al-dostouri [The constructive interpretation of the constitutional judge] (1st ed.). Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

III. Law and Legislation

1. Palestinian Amended Basic Law of 2005.

2. Palestinian Judicial Authority Law.

3. Palestinian Courts Law.

4. Selected rulings of the Palestinian Supreme Constitutional Court.

5. A collection of Palestinian laws.

6. The Egyptian Constitution.

7. A collection of Egyptian laws.

8. The French Constitution.

9. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) (EU) 2016/679.